Backyard Peanut Butter
At Backyard Peanut Butter, we believe peanut butter should never be boring. Forget “smooth or crunchy." We’re here to redefine what peanut butter means to the world.
We live by a maximalist approach to flavor. Every jar is a canvas of creativity, packed with bold, whimsical combinations designed to surprise and delight. From Dill Pickle to Mexican Hot Chocolate, our flavors aren’t just spreads — they’re full-on sensory adventures.
Store in a cool, dry pantry. Refrigeration isn’t required, though it can give you a firmer texture if that’s your vibe. Because this is natural peanut butter, some oil separation is normal when stored outside the refrigerator — just stir before enjoying.
New England made
If you have any questions about products, your order, and/or shipping times, please email shop@thetrustees.org.
All orders ship via USPS (Ground Advantage, Priority or First Class mail), depending on weight, size, and shipping location. A confirmation email and shipment tracking email will be sent to the address used to place the order. Whenever possible, we consolidate orders for products from multiple properties into fewer shipments.
*Please note product descriptions as some items may not be available for shipping & delivery.
Purchase with a Purpose
The Trustees take great care in choosing the products we sell. Our goal is to curate a thoughtful selection of merchandise that easily allows you to be a conscientious consumer. Therefore, our brands and makers must meet at least one of the following criteria:
- Women/LGBTQ+/BIPOC/AAPI-Owned
- Made in New England
- Made in USA
- Eco-Friendly, Sustainable Materials
- Artisan/Small-Batch
- Organic/Sustainably Grown
- Ethically Manufactured
You can feel good knowing your purchase directly supports the Trustees and our mission as well as a multitude of other positive values.